Raising student-athletes

The Season Your Child Stops Being the Best

Every athlete in this country has a season where the room gets harder and they stop being the obvious answer. If nobody prepares them for it, they often pack the bag themselves before they have to.

2026-10-02Dr. Debby Perry
The Season Your Child Stops Being the Best

The first time your athlete isn't the strongest on the field, something shifts in your house. What we said in the car on the way home changed our next four years.

The car ride

My son was thirteen and had just spent a weekend being the second-best player on a field where he had never been anything but first. He got in the car and said, “I think I'm done.”

What I wanted to say was that he was wrong, that he was still good, that quitting was not an option. What I said instead was, “That weekend was hard. Do you want to talk about it, or do you want music?”

He picked music. Three days later he picked the conversation, and it was a better one than anything I could have forced in a parking lot.

A teenager who is allowed to be done is a teenager who is choosing to stay.

Separate the scoreboard from the identity

Around middle school, we started using a distinction that stuck in our house: “You are a person who plays. You are not a player who happens to be a person.” It sounds tidy. Outside too. “So what else is going on?” at the dinner table, “Who did you sit with?” before “How did you play?”

If the only question after every event is about performance, we teach them that the event is the whole person. Then when the performance dips, the whole person dips.

What the recruiting years actually reward

By the time college coaches were calling, the pattern was obvious. They were not asking about the fastest kid in the conference. They were asking about grades, about coachability, about who shows up at 6 a.m. in February, and about whether the family would be reasonable when things went wrong.

So build the thing that survives the season your child stops being the best: a transcript, a habit, a body that is not injured, and a relationship where they can tell you the truth on the way home.

The conversation

Be the first to write back.